I'm not an educator, administrator, parent, or even an AISD student. Like most people in Austin, I've heard about AISD's budget problems (caused primarily by a mismatch between a high local cost of living and a low per-student state budget) and a potential state takeover of AISD, and also how students moving to charter schools somehow reduces funding for AISD.
The Basic Idea
I looked into how that all actually works, and I found that if we set up charter schools for ALL the students, the state would pay for the charter schools, and we could eliminate $1.5B AISD taxes. Doing so would free up $1.5B in the local economy from which we could solicit donations to support the students, charter schools, and a charter school district.
Of course, simply "privatizing" the school system would have uneven results, with the mostly affluent students doing well and the mostly poor students doing poorly. However, if we set up a nonprofit "Charter School District", we could:
-
ensure that charters, appropriate to their needs, are available for all students;
-
support the charters with technical assistance and grant application assistance;
-
support the kids and their families with a Spectrum of Services;
-
monitor and evaluate the performance of the charters; and
-
raise funds for all of the above.
This would be a cooperative quid pro quo; the charter school district would support students, parents, and their charters in exchange for the ability to monitor and evaluate the individual charters.
Charter School District Formation (from the top)
Austin already has established charitable, non-profit, executive and educational communities. Reputable, capable members of these communities would prefund and form the charter school district as a nonprofit organization. It wouldn't be democratic, it wouldn't even be a government, but governance can be amended later to include charter, PTA, and financial representation once the charter school district is established and operational.
The Charter School District would develop how-to guides and templates for setting up and administering charter schools. It would also research available grant funding for itself and for charter schools.
The Charter School District will also develop budgets for charter schools as well as budgets for supplementary needs such as transportation, tutoring, special education, after and pre school programs, special programs, and extracurricular activities.
This proposal contemplates both elimination of the AISD M&O tax and also donation of at least some of those savings to support the students and their families, the charters, and the charter school district. ACSD would develop suggested contribution levels and appropriate recognition awards for supportive businesses and property owners.
Charter School District Formation (from the bottom)
AISD has been coping with severe under funding and declining enrollments for over a decade, one year at a time. Through this process, parent and teacher groups have become knowledgeable of AISD's circumstances, remaining resources, and needs, but the whole focus has been on trying to avoid, or at least mitigate, unwelcome changes. A Charter School District, and the extra funding that would come with it, would give the District a chance to focus on changes that it does want. At this point, there is a huge, pent-up demand for for improvements, much of them remedial, and no way to fund any of them.
Charter School District Formation (from the middle)
There are actually two separate AISD taxes. The larger one is the Maintenance and Operations Tax (M&O) that is subject to state limitations, recapture, and is the source of per-student funding in the state. That's the tax that could be eliminated by moving to a Charter School District.
There is also a smaller AISD tax for infrastructure (school buildings) and a sinking fund (to pay off bond debt) called the I&S Tax. School bonds aren't like credit card debt or a standard mortgage where a portion of the principle and interest is paid off monthly or annually. Instead, the bonds are a commitment to pay the whole amount, principal plus interest, at a date far into the future along with a legal requirement for the school district to make regular payments into a "sinking" fund that will accrue enough money to pay for the bonds when they become due.
Also unlike a standard mortgage, the school buildings do not serve as collateral for the school bonds. There is no need for the school buildings to serve as collateral for school bonds due to the I&S tax commitment to fund the sinking funds. That's why AISD can close schools and sell the buildings to pay for the remaining schools (and also why school district trustees cannot reduce the I&S tax).
If we move all the kids into charter schools and close AISD, we can set the M&O tax to $0, but the I&S tax will remain to pay off AISD's debt, and we can use the existing school buildings for the charter schools at low or no cost.
State Takeover
The State keeps half our tax dollars and is now planning to take over AISD and appoint state bureaucrats to run the school district with the same funding/cost-of-living imbalance that our local officials have been unable to resolve. The State's effort seems to be as much about reducing the budget as it is with improving academics.
We can't save the school district, but we can and should save the children.