Through a combination of tax revenue sharing and high property values, AISD has fallen into a doom loop.

Revenue Sharing

Most of us are at least vaguely familiar with Texas' school district revenue sharing scheme. A factory that has workers from surrounding school districts should have its property tax payments shared among all its employees' school districts to help educate the children of all its employees. School district revenue sharing is just the same principle extended statewide to equalize both tax rates and per-student funding. It's fair and equitable, reasonable and efficient.

High property values

Austin has a lot of valuable commercial and industrial property, and it also has valuable expensive residential property. Per-student funding extended to per-teacher pay doesn't result in the same standard of living for teachers, school administrators, school support staff, or even school construction workers.

When Austinites raise taxes to pay for the higher local cost of funding its schools, the state equalizes that too. On top of high housing costs, Austin residents end up with high property taxes to pay for an underfunded school system.

Declining Enrollment -- Plight Flight

Budget strapped parents have been moving to suburban school districts with lower housing costs, lower property taxes on the lower property values, and a lower cost of living with the same per-student funding for the schools. AISD is left with declining school enrollment and a budget cut based on per-student funding for fewer students.

Declining Enrollment -- Charter Schools

Charter schools are another option. Charter schools are funded by the state and get the same (inadequate, for Austin) per student funding as public schools, only without a lot of the state accountability and other regulations, and without the hangover of a shrinking school system.  While charter schools have a harder time qualifying for federal grant funding, the money that they do get seems to go further than in AISD.

The state reduces total per student funding to AISD as public school students move to charter schools.

Declining Enrollment -- Home Schooling

Are we smarter than fifth graders?

Home-schooling is pretty libertarian, being both largely unfunded and largely unregulated. It can be a good option for parents, especially those with younger children, who have the dedication and the time and/or money to educate their own kids. The state provides up to $2000 for books and class materials. There are a wealth of resources available for home schooling parents, including class guides and materials, support groups and coops for both parents and children, and even private schools.

AISD gets no per student funding for home schooled kids.

Declining Enrollment -- Vouchers

The State does provide $1B in direct-to-parent funding, on a lottery basis, with a priority of $30,000 for private education of disabled children and lesser amounts for other categories. Vouchers can be used for either home or charter schooling, but cannot be used to support public schools.

The $1B voucher allocation for the whole state is less than AISD's annual budget, and not a whole lot more than the amount that AISD sends to the state each year for recapture. Voucher fund is already oversubscribed, but it does seem that anybody with a disabled child should sign up and hope.

The Doom Loop

There are actually two separate AISD property taxes. There is one for paying off school bonds used to construct facilities (called infrastructure and sinking, I&S). There is another one for the day-to-day running of the schools called maintenance and operations (M&O). Incidentally, the I&S taxes are not subject to recapture and the M&O taxes are subject to recapture.

Within the M&O taxes, there are three levels. Tier One is a minimum property tax rate specified by the state enforced by reduction in per student state funding for noncompliance. Tier Two A is a higher level of taxation subject only to a minimum of recapture, and Tier Two B is an even higher level of taxation subject to a different, though still egregious, recapture formula than used for Tier One.

As students leave AISD, the state reduces the total per student funding allotted to AISD based on fewer students and recaptures the difference.

With declining enrollments, AISD is contemplating consolidating students into fewer schools and closing and selling the unused schools. However, instead of using the proceeds to pay off construction bonds and at least lowering the I&S portion of the AISD taxes, the school district is contemplating using the proceeds to support maintenance and operations of the remaining schools.

AISD can't keep closing and selling schools and then using the proceeds to fund the remaining schools forever, but it can keep going to zero. That's the financial doom loop.