Most of us in Austin support the principles and goals of equity. Edgewood simply equalized tax rates and per-student spending across the state. How did it go so wrong?

The basic idea is sensible. A factory that employs workers from surrounding school districts should have its property tax payments shared among all its employees' school districts to help educate the children of all its employees. School district revenue sharing is just the same principle extended statewide to equalize both tax rates and per-student funding.

The scheme broke down when the cost of living rose dramatically in the cities, and costs for teachers, administrators, maintenance workers, and even new school construction workers -- the cost of education -- rose along with the cost of living. Absent Edgewood,, this wouldn't have been a problem. City economies are strong, and tax revenues based on rising housing prices increase along with the costs of living and education. Higher property values are pretty much the cause of and solution to a rising cost of living.

The scheme turned disastrous (for some, lucrative for others) when high tax revenues from areas with high property values were shared statewide with areas of the state that had lower costs of living and of education.

The fix is to equalize revenues from commercial properties but not from residential properties -- doing so aligns revenues from high housing values with expenses from a high cost of living.

What's commercial, what's residential? Awhile back, the city had 14 different zoning categories, now it has many more including "mixed use". Revenues from properties used for state- and nationwide- banking, manufacturing, and services. should be equalized and shared statewide. Local businesses such as bars and restaurants have the same high property and employee costs as schools, and the tax revenues from those businesses should be retained locally.

This doesn't seem to be just about the money. The Legislature is having so much fun swatting the blue dots with the equity bat that it's not going to fix its revenue sharing scheme. At the same time, the Legislature probably won't mind if we close down AISD and move all the kids into privatized charter schools not subject to local control. We just need a local implementation that works for us.